You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
Oh I do get what you said. I just disagree with it. I think we will have to agree to disagree on this topic. IMO snakes obviously "learn" - not to the extent that mammals and birds do - but they do remember things, such as feeding tongs mean "food" and as the article stated, how to locate the hiding spot quickly from memory. The article didn't try to convince us that they are as smart as primates, but that they have good memory-recall abilities. It makes sense, having good memory of certain things can increase your odds of survival.
PS: I enjoy the way you insert trekkie grammar and words into your sentences, only another trekkie (moi) would pick up on because I do it myself.
Doesn't any living thing with memory have the ability to learn? No matter how simple it's memory is, it's still learning isn't it?
Agreed, even my fish (an animal often considered less intelligent than snakes) go nuts as soon as they see the food container. Fish in the wild would have no idea what it was but mine remember because they have learned a visual cue. Learning is learning, higher animals can just learn more complex things.
Oh I do get what you said. I just disagree with it. I think we will have to agree to disagree on this topic. IMO snakes obviously "learn" - not to the extent that mammals and birds do - but they do remember things, such as feeding tongs mean "food" and as the article stated, how to locate the hiding spot quickly from memory. The article didn't try to convince us that they are as smart as primates, but that they have good memory-recall abilities. It makes sense, having good memory of certain things can increase your odds of survival.
PS: I enjoy the way you insert trekkie grammar and words into your sentences, only another trekkie (moi) would pick up on because I do it myself.
Hahah ok,
The M class planet 2 light years from our current position is inhabited by a race of proto-Vulcan Humanoids....
On another note I was trying to convey that the memory which I now have some reason to believe they have is not the same as our memories.
Example: We have very emotional responses to memory and it can affect our decisions, but a reptile would see feeding tongs and think om nom nom nom must eat.
So what I mean is that they may have memory but it is not how we as sentient humans think of it as.
On another note I was trying to convey that the memory which I now have some reason to believe they have is not the same as our memories.
Example: We have very emotional responses to memory and it can affect our decisions, but a reptile would see feeding tongs and think om nom nom nom must eat.
So what I mean is that they may have memory but it is not how we as sentient humans think of it as.
Yeah, I think you missed something in my original post where I specifically asked people not to discuss snake emotions. It's been hashed an rehashed here so many times, and emotion really isn't relevant (or shouldn't be relevant) in a discussion on memory/learning in animals. This is purely a discussion about learning and memory ability.
On another note I was trying to convey that the memory which I now have some reason to believe they have is not the same as our memories.
Example: We have very emotional responses to memory and it can affect our decisions, but a reptile would see feeding tongs and think om nom nom nom must eat.
So what I mean is that they may have memory but it is not how we as sentient humans think of it as.
No one said snake memory was similar to human memory. The only thing proposed by the first post was that snakes can learn.
I'm glad you posted this Pareeeee, I recall reading it a long time back. Snakes learn their way around in the wild...where to hide...otherwise they don't survive. Look at all the snakes that return to hibernation dens, for example. And they've done radio-telemetry studies following released (relocated) snakes...they do not survive new places very well because they do not know where the best hiding places are, to get to quickly in case of excessive hot or cold temperatures or predators. When they are put in a new place, it takes time & luck to find such places to hide before predators find them or conditions do them in.
I used to have a particular snake (a Trans Pecos ratsnake, not that it matters) that remembered & "liked" to thread itself thru the belt-loops on my jeans...clearly this was something she learned & remembered. And I've lived with enough snakes to know they learn who they are safe with (me!) but that's a long story you wouldn't believe anyway.
I make no claims about dissecting snake brains or all that...but they are now finding that other parts of the human brain can take over functions for parts lost...so I have to wonder why anyone here can be SO positive that just because they cannot see a limbic system or whatever in a snake's brain that snake-brains are not compensating with other structures not yet understood. I guess I just don't understand how, if you like snakes, anyone can be so quick to essentially write them off instead of giving the 'benefit of the doubt'?
And besides, if humans are so 'smart', why are we always at war? & always screwing up the planet? I'm not so sure our intelligence is really serving us that well... heck, people aren't even smart enough to limit their reproduction to fit the resources at hand. You'd think by now we could at LEAST figure that one out?! And if I get stuck in a dark alley, I'd rather it be with a snake than my fellow man, I can tell you that.
Your right possum , well said . Anyway regards this thread , that was only what I was pointing out in my post , that indeed snakes do have memory .The little things he does are from memory , and he knows that I am no threat to him . What I was telling you was not in the emotional way , but a logic way . They adapt to what ever is around them , even humans, to survive .
I think the problem is the mere lack of scientific studies on snake intelligence.
Because of this lack of information people end up forming their own (often erroneous) opinions based on what they observe in their snake's behaviour, because they compare it with mammal or other animal behaviour. Something you just can't do with snakes.
On another note I was trying to convey that the memory which I now have some reason to believe they have is not the same as our memories.
Example: We have very emotional responses to memory and it can affect our decisions, but a reptile would see feeding tongs and think om nom nom nom must eat.
So what I mean is that they may have memory but it is not how we as sentient humans think of it as.
How ironic. Your level of sentience in this discussion is exactly what keeps you from understanding that you have not learned enough about the topic. The awareness of subjectivity is not a requirement for learning anymore than being able to chew peanut butter is. Of course they dont learn the same as humans. Humans dont even learn the same as other humans. Why would learning the same way as humans be the criteria for the general capacity to remember information and alter behaviour accordingly?
Ugh, whether or not reptiles learn is not up for debate. They can and do. What is debatable is the speed and method by which they do. This article talks about the surprising ways in which they learn, not whether or not they are able to do so.
__________________
The plural of anecdote is not data
I have great respect for scientific research...but I also think you can over-rely on it. Don't forget that scientists once gave us thalidomide as 'safe' and said it was healthier to substitute margarine (full of trans fats) for butter (merely saturated fats). Research is generally driven by the almighty dollar....we are told things are healthy to consume because some are getting rich selling it, so I wouldn't look for the scientific community to resolve snake brains any time soon...LOL! I agree with you Jarich....snakes "can & do" learn. I also think that people will only see what they want to see...
With my newest video up, I'll have some input. My Reticulated Python displays an astonishing level of intelligence, even when compared to what I have heard about other retics.
One of the most notable examples is that he has learned a signal not at all related to food. When he is out exploring he inevitably tries to get somewhere he is not supposed to go, and sometimes he gets too far to be maneuvered out easily. In this case I simply place a hand on him and firmly hold his midsection. He has learned that this means he can either come out on his own, exactly how he got in, or I will get him out myself. He now reliably and calmly comes out on his own, without getting tangled along the way. I let him go and he continues exploring.
10:40 and 27:24 give examples of this. Oh, and he displays a basic understanding of physics at 28:20....
In my opinion for something to "learn" it must be sentient being.
Example, it has been well documented that primates can learn and solve problems but we know that they have higher brain function and their own kind of emotion, but a snake is known to have limited cognitive capabilities and it is illogical to assume that they can ''learn" as we think of it but rather develop a means to continue living.
Snakes learn. Like my wife said above, look at hook training. It's not a suggestion, it's a fact that it works. The snake learns to respond in certain ways to specific stimuli. It's not a natural instinct, it's a learned behavior.
This is a great subject for a science project for my daughter. I'll bring it up with her.
__________________
Out of the mouth of a child... "He may be cold blooded but he has a warm heart."
humans think of it as.
Linear Mode
