Try putting some vanilla extract on all the mice or spraying them with perfume.... I've done this a few times with success. I prefer the vanilla extract, but either one will work fine.

After you spray the mice... make sure to thoroughly clean out the bin and add completely new shavings, food, ect....
If you don't want to spray them down... try introducing everyone in a neutral bin.
Take care
Annie B. <:3 )~~