Mustangrde1
12-27-03, 12:48 PM
This subject always raises its ugly head. So here is my thoughts and opinions on it. As a person who once had and worked with venomoids I am can see both sides of the story. Fortunately with a lot of research and advise I relised how wrong they are and how horrible the alterations are to them in physical characteristics and fatalities that would not occur if it were not for people seeking pure profit for these animals. I will never again own one as I believe it to be an abomination and there are far better ways to display venomous reptiles for education as I have pointed out below.
Here is anyones chance to state their points on the subject. Try to keep emmotion out of.
Below is a copy from another thread I wrote on.duh
We all see and hear the stories from other countries where animals are slaughtered for their internal organs or skins. These animals in some cases are slaughter for the mythological belief that their organs are an aphrodisiac or medical treatment for any number of diseases. Medical Science has proven time after time this to be false yet it still occurs. When we here of this it is upsetting and disheartening for us.
_
It is very difficult for some of these countries to enforce laws regarding these practices yet they try to with the little resources available. There should be however no excuse in large countries with better resources to enforce cruelty laws and prosecute person in violation of laws regarding cruelty or neglect or practicing surgery without a license on animals which can and does cause loss of life and undo suffering.
_
In The United States alone there are 17 states that have enacted "PET LEMON LAWS" to protect buyers from receiving animals in poor shape or health.
Arizona - Title 44, Chapter 11, Article 17 of the Arizona Revised Statutes "Pet Dealers" section. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 15 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 60 days.
Arkansas - Section 4-97-105 of the Arkansas Code. Applies to dogs and cats only. Health problems are covered for 10 days.
California - HEALTH AND SAFETY CODE, SECTION 122045-122222. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 15 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year. This lemon law is for dogs and cats only.
Connecticut - Section 22-344b of the CT Code. Dogs and cats are covered for health problems for 15 days. Reimbursements for veterinary bills cannot exceed two hundred dollars.
Delaware - Section 4005 of the DE Code. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 20 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 2 years. The animal can be either returned for a full refund of the purchase price, exchanged, or retained. Reimbursement for reasonable veterinary fees cannot exceed the original purchase price of the animal. Parasites are covered if they make the animal clinically ill.
Florida - Florida State Statute 828. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 14 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year.
Maine - Title 7, Part 9, Chapter 745: SALE OF DOGS AND CATS. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 10 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year.
Massachusetts - 330 CMR 12.05. Health problems in dogs and cats are covered for 14 days. Requires a refund or a replacement animal -- no veterinary bill reimbursement.
Minnesota - Section 325F.791 of the MN Code. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 10 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year. This lemon law is for dogs and cats only.
New Hampshire - Section 437.13 of the NH Code. Refunds or substitutions for up to 14 days; does not cover vet bills. Includes dogs, cats, and ferrets.
New Jersey - NJ Statute 56:8-93. Contagious or infectious diseases are covered for 14 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered up to 6 months. The consumer has the right to return the dog or cat and receive a full refund or replacement plus reimbursement of veterinary fees; or retain the dog or cat and receive reimbursement of veterinary fees plus the cost of future veterinary fees.
New York - Article 35-D Section 753 of the General Business Law. Health conditions in dogs and cats are covered for 14 days.
Nevada - Section 574.490 of the Nevada Code. Covers health problems for up to 10 days. Provides refund of purchase price, replacement of equal value, or reimbursement of vet bills, in an amount not to exceed the purchase price of the pet.
Pennsylvania - Contagious or Infectious Diseases are covered: 10 days; Congenital or Hereditary Defects: 30 days
South Carolina - Section 47-13-160 of the SC Code. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 14 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 6 months. Pet store liability for veterinary fees must not exceed fifty percent of the purchase price, including sales tax, of the animal.
Vermont - 20V.S.A. sec. 4302. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 7 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year.
Virginia - 3.1-796.80. Health problems are covered for 10 days. Must return the pet to receive refund or exchange.
Though many of these States specifically cover dogs and cats the same laws can be argued for other pets as well. All 50 States and The Federal Government have Laws again pertaining to Cruelty and neglect of animals and conditions for Surgery and Captive living requirements.
http://www.animal-law.org/statutes/index.html_Great State by state brief
http://www.nal.usda.gov/awic/legislat/awicregs.htm_ Federal laws
This being said it shows that we as a civilized society appall such violations to animals. So when I here the word Venomoid which is a SURGICALLY altered animal for no other reason then profit under the assumption it will be safe to handle it appalls me. The persons performing this alteration are for the most part NOT licensed and therefore violating laws regarding who/whom may perform surgeries. Without proper facilities and narcotics this can and does cause undo fatalities and stress upon animals and is a crime under numerous state laws. Again these people if not licensed are also using narcotics that without the licensing are illegal to own posses and administer.
_I have said that there are only two reasons that I could ever condone these animals and that is in education and research use. However I place it under the stipulations that. "A" The person doing such research or education be licensed for these practices and that they must do a required number of educational demonstrations per year so as to keep persons from acquiring said permit/license just to own a venomoid. " B " That the surgery be performed by a Licensed Veterinary doctor only and only after proof and permits furnished to the Veterinary clinic have been issued by the party wishing to have this surgery performed. I even had a venomoid at one time and was going to use it for educational lectures but with time in my life being what it is I could not. I therefore allowed the animal to be sent on to someone that could. After much research from that time I have learned just how horrible this procedure is and could never again own one as I feel it supports the slaughter of numerous animals for no reason. Proper handling of the real animals or display behind locked cages and allowing an audience to view them via large screen TV during a lecture and then close inspection from in front of glass is far safer and better for the animals.
When we as a society see person doing things we feel are Morally and Ethically and Legally wrong we have the right and responsibility to try and change laws or have laws enforced. Sitting back with no opinion or stance on a subject that is known to cause fatalities and stress for no reason other then profit makes those who stand by and do nothing just as guilty as those who are causing the deaths and stress.
The arguments the people performing these alterations range from they are perfect for training for venomous to they are safer pets. This in itself shows they are purely looking for the all mighty dollar and sell. There is no substitute for proper training with the real animals under supervised instruction from seasoned keepers with knowledge of the animals a person wishes to work with or own in the future.
With mortality rates as high as 90% in some verified cases this shows just how deadly these alteration for profit are to the animals the procedure is performed on. This is part of the reason behind laws to allow for only "trained licensed veterinary doctors to perform a surgery." The Average person possibly could perform this surgery but would have a high mortality rate. The care needed for Pre-op, surgery and post operative care is best left to professionals not back yard butchers. As well as guidelines of established medical laws regarding the surgical standards.
Where we as Keepers fit in is when we are aware of people committing such acts it is our Moral and Ethical along with Legal responsibility to inform the local authorities of their actions and DEMAND action be taken against these people.
Demanding action is a must sitting back passively will do nothing but condone these peoples actions.
Morally and Ethically it is our Duty to inform other Members of the Herp community to these people and their actions. Boycotts against their business and business that do business with these people can in the end stop the needless deaths of animals and their pain and suffering.
We are not 3rd world countries and we do have laws and morals as I provided above. Now it is up to you and I to make certain that when these people who are performing the alterations without the proper legal training as prescribed by law are held accountable
OK that was that. Now some in the hot community will say that taking actions such as this will limit or possibly destroy our ability to own and keep venomous. I look at it a different way.
It shows to the lawmakers WE as a community are willing to police are selves and to not allow practices in our community that are illegal or dangerous. We go to the measure to report people mutilating animals and selling animals they tote to be safe for handling when in fact they can become again venomous if the operation was not performed properly. Also the babies of venomoids are definitely HOT and dangerous. When we as a community are willing to stand up and be counted for what is morally, ethically and legally correct we do not detract from our rights to keep animals. We actually strengthen our ability to do so by showing the potential powers that be our responsibilities and maturity and safety ethics.
It is very hard for people to argue evil against people who have proven we will not allow certain actions in our community.
Here is anyones chance to state their points on the subject. Try to keep emmotion out of.
Below is a copy from another thread I wrote on.duh
We all see and hear the stories from other countries where animals are slaughtered for their internal organs or skins. These animals in some cases are slaughter for the mythological belief that their organs are an aphrodisiac or medical treatment for any number of diseases. Medical Science has proven time after time this to be false yet it still occurs. When we here of this it is upsetting and disheartening for us.
_
It is very difficult for some of these countries to enforce laws regarding these practices yet they try to with the little resources available. There should be however no excuse in large countries with better resources to enforce cruelty laws and prosecute person in violation of laws regarding cruelty or neglect or practicing surgery without a license on animals which can and does cause loss of life and undo suffering.
_
In The United States alone there are 17 states that have enacted "PET LEMON LAWS" to protect buyers from receiving animals in poor shape or health.
Arizona - Title 44, Chapter 11, Article 17 of the Arizona Revised Statutes "Pet Dealers" section. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 15 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 60 days.
Arkansas - Section 4-97-105 of the Arkansas Code. Applies to dogs and cats only. Health problems are covered for 10 days.
California - HEALTH AND SAFETY CODE, SECTION 122045-122222. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 15 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year. This lemon law is for dogs and cats only.
Connecticut - Section 22-344b of the CT Code. Dogs and cats are covered for health problems for 15 days. Reimbursements for veterinary bills cannot exceed two hundred dollars.
Delaware - Section 4005 of the DE Code. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 20 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 2 years. The animal can be either returned for a full refund of the purchase price, exchanged, or retained. Reimbursement for reasonable veterinary fees cannot exceed the original purchase price of the animal. Parasites are covered if they make the animal clinically ill.
Florida - Florida State Statute 828. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 14 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year.
Maine - Title 7, Part 9, Chapter 745: SALE OF DOGS AND CATS. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 10 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year.
Massachusetts - 330 CMR 12.05. Health problems in dogs and cats are covered for 14 days. Requires a refund or a replacement animal -- no veterinary bill reimbursement.
Minnesota - Section 325F.791 of the MN Code. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 10 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year. This lemon law is for dogs and cats only.
New Hampshire - Section 437.13 of the NH Code. Refunds or substitutions for up to 14 days; does not cover vet bills. Includes dogs, cats, and ferrets.
New Jersey - NJ Statute 56:8-93. Contagious or infectious diseases are covered for 14 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered up to 6 months. The consumer has the right to return the dog or cat and receive a full refund or replacement plus reimbursement of veterinary fees; or retain the dog or cat and receive reimbursement of veterinary fees plus the cost of future veterinary fees.
New York - Article 35-D Section 753 of the General Business Law. Health conditions in dogs and cats are covered for 14 days.
Nevada - Section 574.490 of the Nevada Code. Covers health problems for up to 10 days. Provides refund of purchase price, replacement of equal value, or reimbursement of vet bills, in an amount not to exceed the purchase price of the pet.
Pennsylvania - Contagious or Infectious Diseases are covered: 10 days; Congenital or Hereditary Defects: 30 days
South Carolina - Section 47-13-160 of the SC Code. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 14 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 6 months. Pet store liability for veterinary fees must not exceed fifty percent of the purchase price, including sales tax, of the animal.
Vermont - 20V.S.A. sec. 4302. Covers contagious or infectious diseases for 7 days; congenital or hereditary defects are covered for up to 1 year.
Virginia - 3.1-796.80. Health problems are covered for 10 days. Must return the pet to receive refund or exchange.
Though many of these States specifically cover dogs and cats the same laws can be argued for other pets as well. All 50 States and The Federal Government have Laws again pertaining to Cruelty and neglect of animals and conditions for Surgery and Captive living requirements.
http://www.animal-law.org/statutes/index.html_Great State by state brief
http://www.nal.usda.gov/awic/legislat/awicregs.htm_ Federal laws
This being said it shows that we as a civilized society appall such violations to animals. So when I here the word Venomoid which is a SURGICALLY altered animal for no other reason then profit under the assumption it will be safe to handle it appalls me. The persons performing this alteration are for the most part NOT licensed and therefore violating laws regarding who/whom may perform surgeries. Without proper facilities and narcotics this can and does cause undo fatalities and stress upon animals and is a crime under numerous state laws. Again these people if not licensed are also using narcotics that without the licensing are illegal to own posses and administer.
_I have said that there are only two reasons that I could ever condone these animals and that is in education and research use. However I place it under the stipulations that. "A" The person doing such research or education be licensed for these practices and that they must do a required number of educational demonstrations per year so as to keep persons from acquiring said permit/license just to own a venomoid. " B " That the surgery be performed by a Licensed Veterinary doctor only and only after proof and permits furnished to the Veterinary clinic have been issued by the party wishing to have this surgery performed. I even had a venomoid at one time and was going to use it for educational lectures but with time in my life being what it is I could not. I therefore allowed the animal to be sent on to someone that could. After much research from that time I have learned just how horrible this procedure is and could never again own one as I feel it supports the slaughter of numerous animals for no reason. Proper handling of the real animals or display behind locked cages and allowing an audience to view them via large screen TV during a lecture and then close inspection from in front of glass is far safer and better for the animals.
When we as a society see person doing things we feel are Morally and Ethically and Legally wrong we have the right and responsibility to try and change laws or have laws enforced. Sitting back with no opinion or stance on a subject that is known to cause fatalities and stress for no reason other then profit makes those who stand by and do nothing just as guilty as those who are causing the deaths and stress.
The arguments the people performing these alterations range from they are perfect for training for venomous to they are safer pets. This in itself shows they are purely looking for the all mighty dollar and sell. There is no substitute for proper training with the real animals under supervised instruction from seasoned keepers with knowledge of the animals a person wishes to work with or own in the future.
With mortality rates as high as 90% in some verified cases this shows just how deadly these alteration for profit are to the animals the procedure is performed on. This is part of the reason behind laws to allow for only "trained licensed veterinary doctors to perform a surgery." The Average person possibly could perform this surgery but would have a high mortality rate. The care needed for Pre-op, surgery and post operative care is best left to professionals not back yard butchers. As well as guidelines of established medical laws regarding the surgical standards.
Where we as Keepers fit in is when we are aware of people committing such acts it is our Moral and Ethical along with Legal responsibility to inform the local authorities of their actions and DEMAND action be taken against these people.
Demanding action is a must sitting back passively will do nothing but condone these peoples actions.
Morally and Ethically it is our Duty to inform other Members of the Herp community to these people and their actions. Boycotts against their business and business that do business with these people can in the end stop the needless deaths of animals and their pain and suffering.
We are not 3rd world countries and we do have laws and morals as I provided above. Now it is up to you and I to make certain that when these people who are performing the alterations without the proper legal training as prescribed by law are held accountable
OK that was that. Now some in the hot community will say that taking actions such as this will limit or possibly destroy our ability to own and keep venomous. I look at it a different way.
It shows to the lawmakers WE as a community are willing to police are selves and to not allow practices in our community that are illegal or dangerous. We go to the measure to report people mutilating animals and selling animals they tote to be safe for handling when in fact they can become again venomous if the operation was not performed properly. Also the babies of venomoids are definitely HOT and dangerous. When we as a community are willing to stand up and be counted for what is morally, ethically and legally correct we do not detract from our rights to keep animals. We actually strengthen our ability to do so by showing the potential powers that be our responsibilities and maturity and safety ethics.
It is very hard for people to argue evil against people who have proven we will not allow certain actions in our community.